SC Rebukes Samay Raina, Urges Him to Use Platform to Honour SMA Warriors

Comic Samay Raina faced the Supreme Court's ire for jokes about Spinal Muscular Atrophy (SMA) sufferers. The court suggested he use his platform to raise awareness about SMA. This genetic disorder leads to muscle weakness. Instead of financial reparations, the court stressed the importance of dignity for those affected.

The bench proposed that Raina host shows featuring individuals with SMA. These events would highlight their achievements and aid fundraising for timely treatment. "They don't want your money. They want dignity and respect. Use your platform to show their achievements," the bench advised Raina.

Calls for Legal Measures and Dignity

Senior Advocate Aparajita Singh, representing an organisation supporting SMA-affected individuals, criticised Raina's remarks. She noted these comments hinder crowdfunding efforts. "All these children are accomplished and highly talented. When such comments are made on a platform such as this, it becomes difficult for crowdfunding," she stated.

Chief Justice Surya Kant acknowledged the achievements of SMA sufferers, highlighting examples like those in top universities and professions. He stated, "One is in Microsoft, one is in Michigan State University, one is a classical singer, another is an Assamese writer and publisher... one is a PhD in Bioinformatics."

The court urged the Centre to consider a stringent law protecting persons with disabilities from derogatory comments. This proposal was likened to the SC/ST Act, which penalises such demeanours. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta supported this, noting, "Humour cannot be at the cost of someone's dignity."

Promoting Positive Representation

The court also suggested inviting disabled individuals to comedy shows. These events could showcase their talents and support fundraising for their treatment. "We hope and expect that such few memorable events will take place before we hear matter the next date. Let such two programmes be held twice a month," the bench remarked.

Raina previously deposited Rs 2.50 lakh in response to the controversy, but Singh emphasised the need for dignity over financial compensation. "Samay Raina says he deposited Rs 2.50 lakh. But we don't want that. We are here for our dignity," she asserted.