Puerto Rico Natural Resources Secretary Halts Investigation Into Alleged Illegal Construction Linked to Governor's In-Laws

The newly appointed natural resources secretary of Puerto Rico has halted an investigation into alleged illegal construction in a protected area on the island's southwest coast. This decision has led to public discontent. The administrative order was issued shortly after Governor Jenniffer Gonzalez, who assumed office last week, criticised the investigation initiated by the previous administration as "political persecution."

Gonzalez's in-laws, Jose Vargas and Irma Llavona, were among those accused of illegal activities, such as cutting mangroves and modifying a dock at their residence in La Parguera. This area, designated a natural reserve in 1979, is renowned for its bioluminescent bay. Both Gonzalez and her in-laws have denied these allegations.

Political Implications and Reactions

Gonzalez appointed Waldemar Quiles as the new natural resources secretary. She argued that the investigation was politically motivated, occurring before her party's primaries where she defeated former Governor Pedro Pierluisi. Pierluisi has denied any political motives behind the investigation. Quiles' first action was to halt the investigation and propose legalising homes in La Parguera through a fee payable every five years.

Environmental law expert Pedro Saadé criticised this move, stating, "That is illegal," highlighting that there are established procedures for granting concessions on public domain assets. He expressed concern that this decision might set a precedent and weaken protections for other areas facing illegal developments.

Historical Context and Environmental Concerns

La Parguera saw its first structures in the 1960s when fishermen lived in makeshift homes. These have mostly been replaced by upscale residences, which environmentalists argue should be removed. The halted investigation had proposed a USD 25,000 fine against Gonzalez's in-laws and was led by former natural resources secretary Anaís Rodríguez. Rodríguez had previously stated that the investigation should continue under the new administration.

On Friday, Senate President Thomas Rivera Schatz announced on Facebook that the Senate would request an explanation from Quiles regarding his administrative order. He stressed that measures to prevent "selective prosecution" require "caution, transparency and firmness" to avoid perceptions of selective benefits or privileges.

A spokesperson for Puerto Rico's Natural Resources Department did not immediately respond to requests for comment. In written statements to El Nuevo Día newspaper on Friday, Quiles mentioned that his administrative order was prepared by the previous administration. He noted it acknowledges the acquired rights of homeowners in La Parguera and outlines their responsibilities.

The situation remains tense as Puerto Rico grapples with increasing illegal developments and environmental concerns. The decision to halt the investigation has sparked debates about political influence and environmental protection on the island.