Protests Erupt As Javed Akhtar Is Invited To West Bengal Urdu Academy Mushaira

The West Bengal Urdu Academy's decision to invite Javed Akhtar as the chief guest for a mushaira in Kolkata has sparked protests from two Muslim groups. The Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind and the Wahyahin Foundation have expressed their disapproval, claiming Akhtar has consistently "spoken against religion and God." They are demanding that the invitation be rescinded.

Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind, a prominent Indian Muslim organisation established in 1919, is known for advocating religious, educational, and social causes. In a letter to the Urdu Academy, they urged the withdrawal of Akhtar's invitation. They argued that inviting someone who speaks against religion is inappropriate for an event celebrating Urdu literature.

Protests and Objections

Zillur Rahman Arif, General Secretary of Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind Calcutta, voiced his concerns about Akhtar's participation. He stated that people in West Bengal do not appreciate those who speak against Allah and Islam. Arif mentioned that while he had no issues with inviting an atheist, he objected to Akhtar due to his perceived continuous criticism of religion.

The Wahyahin Foundation also joined the protest against Akhtar's invitation. Mufti Shamail Nadwi expressed surprise at the Academy's decision to invite someone who openly criticises faith. He suggested that such individuals negatively influence young minds and proposed a debate on religion with Akhtar.

Historical Context

Jamiat Ulema-e-Hind reminded the Urdu Academy of their past protests against Taslima Nasreen, who was accused of writing against Prophet Muhammad. They warned that if their requests were ignored, they might resort to democratic protests similar to those held against Nasreen.

Akhtar identifies as an atheist but refers to himself as a "cultural Muslim." Despite being raised in a Muslim family, he does not adhere to religious beliefs. The controversy highlights tensions between secularism and religious sentiments within cultural events.

Awaiting Responses

As of now, neither Javed Akhtar nor the Urdu Academy has commented on the situation. The controversy continues to unfold as both organisations await a response from the Academy regarding their demands. The outcome remains uncertain as discussions around freedom of expression and respect for religious sentiments persist.