What Happens If NEET Is Scrapped? Inside CM Vijay’s Push For Class 12-Based Medical Admissions

Tamil Nadu Chief Minister C. Joseph Vijay's demand to abolish NEET and allow states to fill medical seats based on Class 12 marks has reopened one of India's biggest education debates.

The Anitha Case That Changed Tamil Nadu's NEET Debate

One of the biggest reasons Tamil Nadu continues to strongly oppose NEET is the death of 17-year-old S. Anitha in 2017.

Anitha was a bright student from a poor Dalit family in Tamil Nadu's Ariyalur district. She had scored exceptionally high marks in her Class 12 state board examinations and dreamed of becoming a doctor.

Under Tamil Nadu's earlier system, medical admissions were largely based on Class 12 marks, and Anitha would likely have secured an MBBS seat.

However, after NEET became mandatory, she could not score high enough in the entrance exam.

Supporters say the move would help rural and government school students. Critics argue it could create uneven standards and increase corruption in admissions.

So, would this idea actually work in India's education system?

Statement by the Honorable Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu, Thiru. C. Joseph Vijay, urging the Union Government to cancel the NEET based admissions in medical courses and to permit the respective States to fill up seats based on Class 12 marks.
1/2

— CMOTamilNadu (@CMOTamilnadu) May 13, 2026

2/2

மருத்துவப் படிப்புகளில் நீட் (NEET) அடிப்படையிலான சேர்க்கைகளை ரத்து செய்யவும், பன்னிரெண்டாம் வகுப்பு மதிப்பெண்களின் அடிப்படையில் மாநிலங்களே நிரப்ப அனுமதிக்க, ஒன்றிய அரசை வலியுறுத்தி மாண்புமிகு தமிழ்நாடு முதலமைச்சர் திரு.ச.ஜோசப் விஜய் அவர்களின் அறிக்கை#CMJosephVijay‌ pic.twitter.com/R1G6on3Scy

— CMOTamilNadu (@CMOTamilnadu) May 13, 2026

Why Some States Oppose NEET

Tamil Nadu has opposed NEET for years because many leaders believe the exam favours:

• Urban students
• Coaching institute culture
• CBSE students
• Wealthier families

The argument is that students from rural areas or state boards often struggle because NEET is highly competitive and heavily coaching-driven.

Supporters of Vijay's idea say Class 12 marks reflect a student's consistent academic performance over two years instead of one single exam.

They also believe removing NEET could reduce:

• Student stress
• Coaching dependency
• Paper leak controversies
• Financial burden on families

But Removing NEET Could Also Create Major Problems

Critics say abolishing NEET nationwide may create serious challenges.

Before NEET existed, every state and private college had separate admission systems. Students often had to appear for multiple entrance exams across India.

There were also repeated allegations of:

• Capitation fees
• Donation-based admissions
• Lack of transparency
• Different standards across boards and states

NEET was introduced mainly to create:

• One national exam
• Uniform standards
• Merit-based selection
• Transparency in admissions

If admissions return completely to Class 12 marks, experts fear huge differences between state boards could create unfairness again.

For example:

• Some boards are known for stricter marking
• Others give very high scores easily
• Different syllabuses exist across India

A student scoring 98% in one board may not have the same academic level as a student scoring 90% in another board.

What Could Happen If Vijay's Proposal Becomes Reality?

If India accepts this proposal fully, several major changes could happen.

States Would Gain More Power

State governments would once again control admissions to MBBS, BDS and AYUSH seats under their quota.

This would reduce the Centre's role in medical admissions.

Coaching Industry Could Shrink

India's massive NEET coaching industry, especially in cities like Kota and Sikar, could face a major slowdown.

Families currently spend lakhs of rupees on coaching for NEET preparation.

More Weight To School Education

Class 11 and 12 board performance would become extremely important again.
Students may focus more on school studies instead of entrance exam coaching.

Private Colleges Could Face Scrutiny

Critics worry that without a national exam, some private medical colleges could again face allegations of unfair admissions or donation-based systems.

Students Could Face Unequal Standards

One of the biggest concerns is that India has multiple education boards with different marking patterns.

Without a common entrance exam, comparing students nationally could become difficult.

Could A Middle Path Be Possible?

Some education experts believe India may eventually move toward a hybrid model instead of fully removing NEET.

Possible alternatives include:

• Giving weightage to both NEET and Class 12 marks
• Separate weightage for state board students
• Rural student reservation benefits
• Stronger anti-paper leak systems
• More government medical seats

This approach could balance merit, fairness and accessibility together.

Why The Debate Has Become Bigger After The NEET Leak Row

The NEET 2026 paper leak controversy has intensified criticism of the examination system.

Many political parties are now questioning whether a single national exam affecting more than 22 lakh students can truly remain secure and fair.

Repeated paper leak allegations in recent years have weakened public trust in large competitive exams.

That is why leaders like CM Vijay are using the controversy to renew demands for alternative admission systems.

Final Question: Reform NEET Or Remove It?

This is now the biggest question in India's education debate.

Should NEET be completely abolished? Or should the government reform it with stricter security, transparency and better support for disadvantaged students?

The answer may shape the future of medical education in India for decades.