9 states oppose Centre's proposal on IAS officers' central deputation; 8 others give consent
New Delhi, Jan 26: As many as nine non-BJP ruled states have opposed the Centre's proposal that gives it an overriding power while deciding on central deputation of IAS officers, whereas eight others have given their consent, officials said on Wednesday.
A reminder will soon be sent to the states and Union Territories which have not yet responded to the proposal on making changes in the relevant service rules, they said.
Odisha, West Bengal, Maharashtra, Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand and Rajasthan have raised their voice against the amendments, the officials said. On the other hand, Arunachal Pradesh, Manipur, Tripura, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, Gujarat, Haryana and Himachal Pradesh have given their consent, they added.
Karnataka and Meghalaya had opposed the proposal initially sent to them last month but are expected to send a revised proposal, the officials said, adding that Bihar had also opposed the move earlier. While the nine states opposed the suggested changes saying they were against the federal structural of the country, the Centre has defended its proposal asserting that the states are not sparing sufficient number of IAS officers for deputation which is affecting its functioning, the officials said.
Sources in the Department of Personnel and Training (DoPT) said a trend of decreasing representation of IAS officers, up to the joint secretary-level at the Centre, has been noticed as most of the states are not meeting their Central Deputation Reserve (CDR) obligations and the number of officers, sponsored by them to serve at the Centre are much lesser.
Officers
of
the
Indian
Administrative
Service
(IAS)
are
allocated
a
cadre,
which
is
a
state/states
or
states
and
Union
territories.
Every
cadre
is
allowed
a
CDR
to
ensure
that
officers
have
the
opportunity
to
work
on
central
deputation,
which
adds
to
their
experience.
According
to
DoPT
sources,
the
number
of
IAS
officers
on
CDR
has
gone
down
from
309
in
2011
to
223
as
on
date.
The
DoPT
has
recently
proposed
changes
in
the
IAS
(Cadre)
Rules,
1954
that
will
take
away
the
power
of
states
to
override
the
Centre's
request
for
seeking
officers
on
central
deputation.
Odisha,
in
its
opposition,
said
once
the
move
comes
into
force,
it
will
affect
the
administration
of
states
and
have
an
impact
on
the
implementation
of
various
development
projects.
Describing
the
proposed
amendments
as
"draconian" and
intended
to
promote
unilateralism,
Jharkhand
Chief
Minister
Hemant
Soren
has
asked
Prime
Minister
Narendra
Modi
to
"bury"
the
proposal.
West
Bengal
Chief
Minister
Mamata
Banerjee,
first
to
air
her
voice
against
the
move,
has
urged
Modi
to
withdraw
the
proposal
as
it
would
"create
a
fear
psychosis
among
officers
and
impact
their
performance".
Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M K Stalin has also asked the prime minister to drop the move that "strikes at the very root" of the nation's federal polity and states autonomy. Rajasthan Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot has said the proposed changes will violate the constitutional jurisdiction prescribed for the central and state governments, and reduce the spirit of working fearlessly and faithfully by the officers. Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel has said the proposed amendments are against the spirit of federalism and if implemented may lead to "collapse" of administrative system of states.
Information and Broadcasting Secretary Apurva Chandra, an IAS officer of Maharashtra cadre, had on Friday said working with both the Centre and state governments broadens the perspective of the officers. Citing shortage, the DoPT has been writing to the states seeking more officers on central deputation. It had in June last year asked all state governments to nominate more officers for central deputation at the level of deputy secretary, director and joint secretary.
According to the DoPT proposal, sent to chief secretaries of all state governments on January 12, "in specific situations where services of cadre officer(s) are required by the central government in public interest, the central government may, seek the services of such officer(s) for posting under the central government...and the state government concerned shall give effect to the decision of the central government within the specified time".
It further states that "wherever the state government concerned does not give effect to the decision of the central government within the specified time, the officer(s) shall stand relieved from cadre from the date as may be specified by the central government". Existing rules allowed mutual consultation for the officers' central deputation. The DoPT had written to chief secretaries of all state governments on December 20, 2021, after which reminders were sent on December 27, 2021 and January 6 and January 12. The January 12 letter to states specifically mentions the Centre's power to override the states' disagreement on sending the officers on deputation. PTI