How Jeb Bush's end in South Carolina resembled Rahul Gandhi's defeat in 2014
The unsuccessful run of Jeb Bush, the son and brother of two former American presidents, in this year's presidential election bears a resemblance with that of Rahul Gandhi, the Congress vice-president, in the Lok Sabha election in 2014. Like Bush who failed to last his entire journey despite having a good start, Rahul had seen his party getting decimated in the Indian election two years ago.
Both the leaders found themselves buried under the baggage of the anti-dynastic sentiments.
Jeb Bush represented a fresh beginning but still couldn't make it
Jeb Bush, the former governor of Florida, was seen as a representative of a fresh Republican appeal that spoke of multiculturalism, a family that always had a closeness with the presidency (his father George H W Bush had served one year term while his elder brother George W Bush had served two terms) and had a robust fundraising mechanism. But these advantages did not help Bush in the final count as could not survive the onslaught launched by Donald Trump and bowed out in the initial phase of the race.
The
defeat
of
Bush
and
the
victory
of
Trump
may
herald
a
new
reality
in
the
Republican
Party
but
that
is
something
more
related
to
America's
internal
political
dynamics.
From
Bushes
to
Gandhis:
Heirs
have
been
hit
by
their
dynastic
legacies
For a generalistion which can transcend national borders, the defeats of Bush and Rahul signify that voters harbour little sympathy for leaders who personify an establishment which is perceived to be on the wrong side of popular trust. Jeb Bush tried to revive his family's political fortunes that were hit by his brother's misadventures but failed.
Both Jeb & Rahul saw how dynasties have lost relevance for today's generations
Rahul, on the other hand, too, tried to present his party which has given India three prime ministers as a strong alternative to Narendra Modi, currently the prime minister of India, but didn't succeed. Today, the Congress is a weak force in a system which has undergone a sea change and what has traditionally been perceived as its strong point---the Gandhi family---is being seen as a disadvantage today.
Trump
has
done
to
Jeb
Bush
what
Modi
did
to
Rahul
Modi
emerged
on
the
ruins
of
a
Congress
that
was
seen
with
contempt,
thanks
to
the
anti-incumbency
feelings
that
have
kept
on
piling
up
over
decades
and
also
the
general
dissatisfaction
with
the
Congress-led
UPA
government
that
preceded
Modi's
NDA
government.
The
Emergency
which
was
imposed
by
Rahul's
grandmother
Indira
Gandhi
or
the
Bofors
scam
that
broke
out
during
his
father
Rajiv
Gandhi's
time
still
kept
the
gap
between
the
party
and
the
voters
wide.
New realities have also given the dynastic traditionalism a body blow
On the top of it, the rise of the new middle-class, felicitated by the economic liberalisation, added to the Congress's woes as Modi's tech-savvy and smarter moves gave the grand-old party little opportunity to even come close in the elections that followed. The Congress was reduced to its lowest-ever number of Parliament while Modi repeated something that Rahul's predecessors could only do till that time: get an absolute majority.
Jeb Bush, similarly failed to gauge the voters' actual mode and harboured a thought that travelled on a straight line: That the Americans would pick a candidate who is more a part of the establishment and not someone who spoke colourful things to steal the headlines. But it didn't happen and the refined Republicanism that Bush presented was rejected mercilessly.
Even
family
members
couldn't
save
Jeb
Bush
or
Rahul
by
campaigning
for
them
Bush
even
tried
to
save
the
day
by
roping
in
his
mother,
former
First
Lady
Barbara
Bush
and
brother
George
W
Bush.
But
even
the
family
support
couldn't
do
it
for
him.
Just
like
Sonia
Gandhi
and
Priyanka
Gandhi
failed
to
drive
home
Rahul's
case
in
India.
Both Bush and Rahul perhaps represent a political legacy which has been outlived and even a bright past cannot do much in resurrecting their present and future.