Mamata Banerjee's last 4 visits to Delhi have produced pathetic results: Has she lost her clout?
Mamata
Banerjee
was,
till
recently,
a
heavyweight
politician
in
national
politics
for
her
weight
used
to
be
felt
more
in
New
Delhi
than
her
state
West
Bengal.
Since
her
spectacular
debut
in
the
Lok
Sabha
in
1984
when
she
defeated
a
strong
opponent
like
Somnath
Chatterjee
from
Jadavpur
constituency
in
Kolkata,
Banerjee
was
always
in
the
scheme
of
things
in
politics
at
the
Centre
till
2011,
when
she
took
over
as
the
chief
minister
of
her
state
after
a
historic
victory
over
the
Left
who
once
looked
invincible.
[The
rise
and
fall
of
Mamata
Banerjee]
Since
her
2011
victory,
Mamata
has
lost
her
ground
nationally
Since that victory, Banerjee, quite surprisingly saw her image diminishing fast as far as the politics at the Centre is concerned. Between early 2012 and end of 2014, Banerjee saw herself at the receiving end whenever she tried to reassert her influence on the national stage.
Dilli Ka Laddoo not suiting Mamata anymore?
We
have
four
examples
from
the
recent
past
which
tell
that
the
Dilli
Ka
Laddoo
is
somehow
not
suiting
the
leader
any
more,
irrespective
of
her
identity
as
a
popular
leader
who
rose
from
the
grassroots
level.
Take
the
example
of
June
2012
when
Banerjee,
in
a
zeal
to
corner
the
Congress,
decided
not
to
support
Pranab
Mukherjee
as
the
then
UPA
government's
presidential
candidate.
She
was
embarrassed
by
Mulayam
Singh's
U-turn
on
Pranab
Mukharjee's
presidential
candidature
Despite
being
a
part
of
the
UPA,
the
Trinamool
Congress
supremo
tried
to
stage
a
political
drama
with
Samajwadi
Party
chief
Mulayam
Singh
Yadav,
giving
rise
to
the
speculation
that
the
two
regional
parties
could
forge
an
alternative
alliance
to
the
UPA
(Narendra
Modi
was
yet
to
begin
his
sprint
then).
But
the
cunning
Mulayam
took
a
U-turn
at
the
last
moment
to
jump
into
the
Congress's
fold,
so
drastically
that
Banerjee
was
left
red-faced
before
the
entire
nation.
Heckled
by
alleged
Left
supporters
in
Delhi
and
the
retaliation
in
Bengal
The next incident occurred in April 2013. Banerjee and her finance minister Amit Mitra were on their way to meet the Planning Commission officials when they were heckled allegedly by Left supporters in retaliation to the killing of a SFI student in Kolkata. Banerjee was furious with the incident and a huge political revenge was witnessed in Kolkata within hours.
This
instant
revenge
impacted
Banerjee's
image
as
an
administrator
before
the
entire
nation
for
she
was
expected
to
author
a
change
from
the
routine
violence
in
the
state
as
was
seen
during
the
Left's
dominance.
Anna
Hazare's
mysterious
absence
stunned
Mamata
ahead
of
the
Lok
Sabha
polls
The third event took place on March 2014 when Banerjee went to Delhi to attend a rally with social activist Anna Hazare but the latter pulled out at the last moment, leaving Banerjee facing almost an empty audience arena. It was a big blow for a leader who has known to be a crowd puller.
Frequent changing of alliance has hit Mamata Banerjee's credibility in Delhi
Hazare had endorsed Banerjee as the prime ministerial candidate a few days ahead of this fiasco and with a few showing interest in her rally as against Modi who was sprinting ahead of all at the time, Banerjee's all-India stature was damaged badly.
Congress's 'lack of interest' at Nehru's birth anniversary celebration left Mamata Banerjee dejected
The fourth and the final instance of Banerjee's ‘national failure' happened last week when she went to the national capital to join the Congress's event commemorating Jawaharlal Nehru, India's first prime minister. Banerjee was even found hinting at patching up with the Left, her eternal enemy, to stop the rise of the BJP in Bengal in the recent times. This is also the time when serious charges of corruption has rattled Banerjee's party and her administration is accused of compromising with the nation's security by giving shelter to terrorists.
Banerjee even met top BJP leaders except Prime Minister Modi who was not in the country then, which left political observers guessing about her immediate plans.
The TMC leader was clearly in a dual state of mind of putting up a 'brave' ideological battle up front while engaging through back-channels to save the faces of herself and the party. But all in all, Banerjee's latest trip to Delhi was far unsatisfactory for her political plans about a future alliance against Modi never took off.
Did Banerjee make a mistake in taking over the CM's responsibility in Bengal? Should she have continued with her presence in Delhi?
Was Banerjee's decision to take over as the CM of a beleaguered state like Bengal a big mistake? For given her performance as the administrator, would it have been better if she continued as a politician at the Centre and keep herself away from the daily hassles of state administration? For now, it looks the leader has lost her touch with the capital of politics and might find it difficult to reclaim the lost space.