The 24-year-old has beaten Harry Potter star Daniel Radcliffe, 19, to be named the most-fancied fella among the nation's gays.
"Hamilton is obviously one of the country's most valued stars - he is the David Beckham of Formula 1. He's got the looks, the talent and the personality and he seems like a metrosexual male," the Daily Star quoted website spokesman Adrian Gillan as saying.
Prince Harry came third, followed by Jonny Wilkinson and Prince William.
Top five guys for gays to date:
1. Lewis Hamilton
2. Daniel Radcliffe
3. Prince Harry
4. Jonny Wilkinson
5. Prince William