Left sticks to its guns on Nuke deal
New
Delhi,
Sep
19:
The
differences
between
the
ruling
UPA
and
the
Left
parties
over
the
Indo-US
Nuclear
deal
appear
irreconcilable
with
the
two
sides
sticking
to
their
guns
on
the
pact
at
the
second
meeting
of
the
"political
mechanism" formed
by
them
to
avert
a
crisis
for
the
39-month-old
Manmohan
Singh
government.
Though Panel convener and External affairs Minister Pranab Mukherjee said the two-hour meeting was "constructive," Left leaders said they were not convinced by any of the arguments put forward by the government in favour of the deal.
"We have discussed several issues raised in the notes circulated by both the sides," Mr Mukherjee told mediapersons, while refusing to give any more details of the deliberations of the meeting which is officially described as "inconclusive." The next meeting of the 15-member panel would be held on October 5. In between, the Left would send another note to the UPA on September 24 and the ruling coalition would reply to it on September 27.
The two sides are undertood to have refused to budge from their known positions on the implications of the Hyde Act on the country's security and its foreign policy.
CPI General Secretary A B Bardhan said both the sides discussed the notes they had exchanged recently on a wide range of issues connected with the deal, including the implications of the Hyde Act on the 123 agreement, its impact on the country's foreign policy and security needs, and the economic viability of nuclear energy.
Barring Finance Minister P Chidambaram, who is abroad, all 15 members of the panel were present.
An indication of the deadlock came when the four Left parties today met and outrightly rejected the UPA's response to their September 14 letter explaining their stand on the Hyde Act.
"We
have
refuted
and
rebutted
everything
that
the
government
had
stated
in
response
to
the
issues
raised
by
us
in
our
September
14
letter,"
Mr
Bardhan
told
UNI